Chief Ernest Arnold watches the film “Hear the Call”. Arnold’s opposition to salmon farming in B.C. is central to the film. Tim Collins/Black Press

Camosun screens film focused on fish farming fracas

Opposition calls for cancellation of permits

A diverse audience, all concerned with the issue of farmed salmon, came to Camosun College on Saturday for a screening of a film entitled “Hear the Call” and came away with a renewed conviction that they need to do what they could do to halt the aquaculture process.

The film, by Nat Geo explorer and filmmaker, Josh Thome, provided a focal point for opponents of fish farms as the province approaches a decision on whether some 22 licences for the open pen fish farms come up for renewal this month.

The aquaculture industry in B.C., largely owned by Norwegian interests, is nervously watching how the B.C. NDP government will act in regard to fish farms as those 22 licences represent a substantial proportion of the 36 tenures currently in operation.

A group of Indigenous communities in the Broughton Archipelago has been fighting to have fish farms completely removed from their traditional territories and say that those operations should be moved into on-land operations, completely separated from wild fish stocks.

“These farms pose a significant risk to wild fish stocks, not only in B.C. but in a global sense,” said John Werring, senior scientist and policy advisor for the David Suzuki Foundation and one of the speakers at Saturday’s film screening.

“The two biggest problems (with open net fish farms) are parasites and pathogens. When sea lice infest those farms they multiply by the millions and they will eventually spread to the wild salmon populations. The pathogens within farmed salmon populations also reproduce by the billions. Those viruses are excreted by the penned fish and the tide washes them out into the wild populations.”

In 2012, Dr. Kyle Garver testified at the Cohen Inquiry into the Decline of the Fraser Sockeye that a farm with 1,000,000 fish could shed 650 billion viral particles/hour.

During the last provincial election campaign, the now governing NDP spoke out about the need to rethink the practice of fish farming in B.C. During the campaign, now Premier John Horgan said, unequivocally, that the permits for the aquaculture operations should not be renewed when they come up for consideration in June.

Those definitive statements appear to be somewhat muted as Agriculture Minister Lana Popham has called upon Ottawa to step up regulation of aquaculture on the west coast, stating that’ while the province has “huge concerns,” it is the federal government that “holds most of the cards” on the issue.

While declining to be interviewed, Popham issued the following statement.

“Our government is committed to continuing discussions with First Nations in the Broughton Archipelago so that we can reach a resolution regarding open-pen fish farms in the region. It would be premature to pre-suppose the outcome of those discussions, but we certainly all share a commitment to protecting wild salmon for the cultural and economic benefits they bring to B.C.”

Chief Ernest Alfred of the ’Namgis First Nation, who was present at the screening, spoke out vehemently against the practice of open-net fish farming. Alfred has led recent protests and occupations against the practice in the Broughton Archipelago in the hopes of raising public awareness about the practice.

“I am not anti farming or anti jobs…I am in favour of protecting wild salmon. There are a handful of First Nations who have signed agreements as a matter of economic desperation, but if you look at their books, it hasn’t actually helped those communities. A few men have gotten very rich, but the First Nations people have seen little or no benefit,” said Alfred.

“I’m pretty confident that there will be no renewals (of the fish farm permits). The NDP promised that they would not renew these permits and we have to hold them to that. If concessions are made to farmed salmon, we will be holding Mr. Horgan accountable.”

Sean Hall, a spokesperson for the B.C. Salmon Farming Association, said that the industry is committed to responsible aquaculture and has invested a great deal of money to improve practices, including finding ways of treating fish infected with parasites and developing better fish pens with a view to preventing escapes of farmed fish.

“Half the fish the human race consumes is farmed and the U.N. predicts that it will soon be two thirds of world consumption. This industry actually saves wild fish stocks from over fishing,” said Hall, adding that, should the industry be forced to move production to on-land facilities “it would effectively shut down the industry’ at the cost of as many as 6,600 jobs in B.C., 20 per cent of whom are First Nations workers.

Werring had said that he was aware of these claims and pointed to a fish farming operation opening in Florida slated to produce 90,000 metric tonnes of fish annually in an on-land facility. That amount, said Werring, is the equivalent to the entire production of B.C. Salmon farms.

“We are paying attention to all the concerns about salmon farming and taking steps to address those concerns. In the end, we are about responsibly feeding a hungry world, said Hall.

For his part, filmmaker Thome said that he was pleased with the fact that his film has helped to provide a platform for opposition to the practice of open net salmon farming.

“There are better ways to farm salmon and it’s time that we put an end to what is a very toxic practice. We need to respect the wishes of the First Nations along our coastline and we need to respect safety of natural wild salmon along our coastline,” said Thome.

 

Film maker Josh Thome was at the first screening of his film about salmon farming in B.C. (photo / Tim Collins)

Just Posted

Oak Bay’s voter turnout highest in 10 years

Voter turnout in Oak Bay significantly higher than provincial average

Man breaks into Victoria residence while two teens are home

VicPD seek suspect described as Caucasian male in his 50s with long grey and brown hair and stubble

Multiple earthquakes off Vancouver Island recorded around the world

Five earthquakes overnight on Oct. 21 were measured as ‘strong’

West Shore RCMP seizes Camp Namegans’ U-Haul truck

Lock and gate damaged at Thetis Lake Campground in View Royal

Police briefs: two break and enters last week in Oak Bay

Two bicycles found by police waiting to be claimed by the rightful owners

WATCH: Murdoch defeats Jensen for mayor’s seat

Kevin Murdoch excited about strength of team joining him at the council table

B.C. government moves to tighten resource industry regulations

New superintendent will oversee engineers, biologists, foresters

Election watchdog seeks digitally savvy specialists to zero in on threats

Move follows troublesome evidence of online Russian interference in the 2016 U.S. election

More court before Dutch man charged in Amanda Todd case is extradited here

Appeals must be dealt with in Europe, before charges faced in B.C.

Crown says man guilty of B.C. girl’s 1978 murder based on alleged confession

Jury hears details of girl’s 1978 murder while Crown says man should be convicted of girl’s murder based on alleged confession.

BCHL alumni has NHL jersey retired by Anaheim Ducks

Paul Kariya played with the Penticton Vees from 1990-1992

Most Read