Letter: Uplands residents’ sewer position clarified

Residents strongly support Option 1 or Option 2 (gravity sewer) over Option 3 (pressurized sanitary sewer)

Re: Uplands residents reject individual pumps as sewer separation solution, Oak Bay News Feb. 5.

Thank you for placing the Uplands sewer separation project on the front page of the Feb. 5 edition of your paper.

Those of us who presented at the Feb. 2 Oak Bay committee of the whole are pleased that you are giving this important issue the attention that it deserves.

As I was the presenter named in your article, I would like to make two comments on the report of our presentation.  Possibly we did not speak with adequate clarity.

We strongly support Option 1 or Option 2 (gravity sewer) over Option 3 (pressurized sanitary sewer). Your reporting said that we supported Option 1. At this point it is not clear to us which of Options 1 and 2 would be preferred.

We ask that Option 3 be rejected and that Options 1 and 2 be evaluated further so that a knowledgeable selection can be made. There are issues such as the failure of a sanitary pump versus the failure of a storm water one.

We also commented briefly on the three hybrid schemes, Options 4, 5 and 6.

Prior to the meeting, we understood that our presentation time would be limited, thus we focused on the main issue of gravity sewer versus a pressurized sanitary sewer.  So possibly our comments here were too brief to be noted.

We noted that hybrid Options 4, 5 and 6 were of limited merit. The cost might be less but many more home owners would have to install and operate pumps (an additional 166, 174 and 136 pumps respectively), a very undesirable requirement in our view.

It should also be noted that for these three options, the municipality would have to build and operate additional pumping stations (an equally undesirable outcome).

Geoff Buck

Oak Bay



Just Posted

Trial date delayed in case of slain Oak Bay sisters

Case of Andrew Berry, charged in deaths of daughters, will reconvene in three weeks

GALLERY: Snow Day in Oak Bay

Giant snowmen, tobogganing, and a quiet golf course

BC SPCA proposes fines for animal mistreatment, reduction in commercial trade

Animal welfare group’s ideas brought to Victoria councillors

Duncan family says care home switched mom’s cat with robot cat

Staff alleged to have said they were taking cat for bath, then replaced her with robotic stuffed toy

New Victoria graving dock will offer high-paying jobs

New facility will reuse and treat any water required for repair process

GALLERY: Snow Day in Oak Bay

Giant snowmen, tobogganing, and a quiet golf course

Suspected serial killer targeting Toronto gay community now faces six murder charges

Bruce McArthur now charged with murders of six men: Toronto police

Trump suggests more guns in schools to combat shootings

Trump floats two-step plan for gun control: More guns, more control

Second Russian athlete tests positive for doping at Olympics

Russian Bobsled Federation states a drug-test sample that pilot Nadezhda Sergeeva gave on Sunday was positive.

Pearkes opens doors to home renovation and decor expo

Plenty of ideas for homeowners at Victoria Early Spring Home Expo running Friday through Sunday

Indigenous leaders call for change after ‘system fails’ Tina Fontaine

‘All of us should be ashamed’: Calls for change after jury finds Raymond Cormier not guilty

Atwal fiasco dogs Trudeau; PM pledges a ‘conversation’ with MP responsible

Trudeau is being peppered with questions about the lingering controversy

Germany upsets Canada in Olympic men’s hockey

Germany 4 Canada 3; Germans play OAR for gold; Canada and Czechs go for bronze

Suspect and Mountie bitten by police dog during arrest near Nanaimo

Two suspects were arrested in connection with a stolen pickup truck in Cassidy on Thursday evening

Most Read